Quick Answer

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy comes down to fees, rules and control. On a standard US sale above about $8, Etsy’s base fees (10% to 12.5% of a $15 to $100 order) cost less than Amazon Handmade’s flat 15%. An order that comes through Etsy’s Offsite Ads costs more than the same sale on Amazon. Etsy lets anyone open a shop and allows production partners, digital files and craft supplies. Amazon Handmade needs approval and accepts only goods you make yourself, but it charges no listing fee, waives the $39.99 monthly plan after month one, and offers FBA and Prime. Many makers sell on both.


If you make things by hand, Etsy and Amazon Handmade are the two big marketplaces built for you. They look similar from the outside. Up close, they charge differently, accept different products and give you very different control over your shop.

This comparison puts both side by side with the rates published in October 2026: what each one takes from the same order, who can sell what, how returns and custom orders work, and which one fits your business.


About the Author: Gloria Anderson writes for the SellerSonar editorial team about Amazon selling programs, fees and marketplaces. She checks every Amazon rule in her articles against Amazon’s own help pages, and every fee example against the platforms’ published rates.


Amazon Handmade vs Etsy at a Glance

Here is the short version for a US seller. Every row is explained further down.

Amazon Handmade Etsy
Who can sell Approved makers only, after an application Anyone who opens a shop
What you can sell Goods you make, hand-alter or upcycle yourself (small team allowed) Items made, designed, handpicked or sourced by you, incl. production partners, vintage, supplies and digital files
Monthly fee $39.99 in month one, then waived None
Listing fee None $0.20 per listing, renewed every 4 months
Fee per sale 15% of the order total (minimum $0.30) 6.5% transaction fee + 3% + $0.25 processing
Ads fee on outside traffic None Offsite Ads: 15% or 12% per attributed order, capped at $100
Fulfillment by the platform FBA available (not for custom items) No, you ship
Returns Must accept within 30 days (custom items exempt) You set the policy per listing
Countries US, CA, MX, UK, DE, FR, IT, ES stores One global marketplace

What Is Etsy?

Etsy is an online marketplace for creative goods. In its third quarter 2026 shareholder letter (October 28, 2026), Etsy reported about 88 million active buyers over the previous twelve months and more than 100 million listings.

Etsy’s scope is wider than “handmade”. Its rules on what you can sell say every item “must either be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by you.” In practice that covers:

  • Made by you: items made by hand or with computerized tools like a 3D printer, CNC or Cricut machine.
  • Designed by you: your design printed by a production partner (print on demand), or digital downloads. You must disclose the production partner in the listing.
  • Handpicked: vintage items at least 20 years old, and curated collections.
  • Sourced: craft supplies, party decorations and personalized items.

There is no application. You open a shop, pay a one-time set-up fee if your location has one, and start listing.

What Is Amazon Handmade?

Amazon Handmade is a maker-only store inside Amazon, launched in 2015. In 2020, Amazon said its makers came from all 50 US states and more than 80 countries, and that it had “more than 300 million active customers around the world” (Amazon press release, February 2020). Amazon publishes no shopper count for Handmade alone.

The entry rules are strict. Amazon reviews an application, and products must be made by you or a small team (fewer than 20 people is preferred). Hand tools and light machinery are fine; assembly lines and automation are not. Amazon’s Handmade category rules also ban outsourced production, drop-shipping, reselling, digital products, food and most craft supplies.

Once approved, your products appear in the Handmade store and in regular Amazon search results. That second part matters: a shopper searching “wooden cutting board” on Amazon sees your board next to factory-made ones. Our Amazon Handmade seller guide covers the requirements and the application step by step.

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy Fees: What You Pay on the Same Order

Fees are where most makers start, so here is the same US order run through both price lists. “Order total” means item price plus shipping, before sales tax.

Amazon Handmade vs Etsy fees on $15, $40 and $100 US orders: Amazon 15%, Etsy standard sale 10% to 12.5%, Etsy Offsite Ads orders 22% to 27.5%
Fees on a $15, $40 and $100 seller-shipped order in the US, from Amazon’s and Etsy’s published rates, checked October 30, 2026.

Three things stand out:

  • A standard Etsy sale is cheaper on most orders. On a $100 order, Etsy takes $9.95 and Amazon takes $15.00. Etsy’s fixed $0.45 (listing plus processing) only makes it more expensive below about $8.
  • An Offsite Ads order flips it. The same $100 order costs $24.95 on Etsy if the buyer came from one of Etsy’s ads on Google or social media.
  • Amazon’s rate never changes. 15% of everything the buyer pays, including shipping and gift wrap, with a $0.30 minimum.

Amazon Handmade fees

Amazon’s own fee table for Handmade shows the same 15% and $0.30 minimum in every category, from jewelry to toys. There are no listing, transaction or payment processing fees on top.

Amazon Seller Central help page Amazon Handmade: Referral fees, showing a 15% referral fee and $0.30 minimum in every Handmade category
Amazon’s Handmade referral fee table in Seller Central help (G201814220), checked October 30, 2026.

Two conditions apply, both from Amazon’s Handmade referral fee page:

  • You need the Professional selling plan. It “typically costs $39.99 per month”, but per Amazon’s Handmade page, after the first month the fee is waived for approved makers, “a savings of $480 per year.”
  • If you’re approved for Handmade but stay on the Individual plan, Amazon’s standard referral fees apply instead. Our guide to Individual vs Professional seller plans explains the difference.

If you use FBA, Amazon’s fulfillment fees come on top of the 15%.

Etsy fees

Etsy’s fees and taxes page lists more moving parts:

  • Listing fee: $0.20 per listing. A listing expires after 4 months, and each auto-renewal costs another $0.20 “regardless of resulting sales.” Fifty slow-moving listings kept live all year cost $30 even if none sells.
  • Transaction fee: 6.5% of the order total, including shipping and gift wrap.
  • Payment processing: 3% + $0.25 per order for a US shop, per Etsy’s processing fee table. It also applies to sales tax if you charge it.
  • Currency conversion: 2.5% if your listing currency differs from your bank account currency.
  • Set-up fee: one-time and non-refundable, in some locations.

Etsy Offsite Ads: the fee that changes the math

Etsy advertises listings on search engines, social media and partner sites. If a buyer clicks one of those ads and buys from your shop within 30 days, you pay an extra fee on that order. Etsy’s Offsite Ads page sets two tiers:

Your shop’s sales in any 365 days Fee per attributed order Can you opt out?
Always under $10,000 15% Yes
$10,000 or more, at any point 12% No, “for the lifetime of your shop”

The fee per order is capped at $100. For a growing shop, this is the line to watch: once you cross $10,000 in sales, every order that Etsy attributes to an offsite ad costs you 12% on top of the base fees, permanently.

💡 Expert Tip: Before you compare platforms, pull your last 3 months of Etsy orders and check how many were attributed to Offsite Ads. If it’s a large share, your real Etsy cost is closer to 22% than 10%, and Amazon Handmade’s flat 15% may be the cheaper channel for the same products.

Etsy’s own numbers show how much ads add up. In the third quarter of 2026, Etsy’s take rate (its revenue as a share of gross sales) was 26.2%, up 0.5 points from a year earlier. Etsy credited the increase mainly to Etsy Ads and partly to Offsite Ads. That figure includes optional services like ads and shipping labels, so it isn’t what any one shop pays. It does show that base fees are only part of the bill.

Audience and Competition

Etsy’s buyers shop on a marketplace built around handmade, vintage and personalized goods. That’s the main reason makers start there. The trade-off is a crowded marketplace with more than 100 million listings competing for the same searches.

Amazon’s shoppers are mostly searching for a product, not for “handmade”. Your listing competes in regular Amazon search with mass-produced items that are often cheaper. Inside the Handmade store itself, everyone has passed the same approval, so the competition is other makers.

Neither platform publishes conversion rates or traffic by category, so treat any claim that one “converts better” with caution. What you can measure is your own result: list the same product on both and compare views, sales and fees after a few months.

Shop Control, Returns and Customer Contact

This is the difference makers feel most once they’re selling.

On Etsy, the shop is yours to shape. You choose how your shop looks, use your own photos and set your own return policy per listing. Etsy’s return policy rules require sellers outside the EU to set a policy on every physical listing, “even if it is to let buyers know you do not accept returns.” Its simple template offers 30 days, buyer pays return shipping.

On Amazon, Amazon sets more of the rules. You get a maker profile, but listings follow Amazon’s catalog format and title rules. Amazon’s Handmade returns page requires you to accept return requests within 30 days of delivery and to respond within 24 hours. Customized items can’t be returned unless there was a seller error, damage, or the item is materially different from the listing.

Customer contact differs too. Etsy buyers can message you before they buy, which helps with custom orders. On Amazon, messaging runs through Amazon’s buyer-seller system and its rules.

Custom Orders, Shipping and Prime

Personalized goods sell on both platforms, but the mechanics differ.

  • Etsy: add a personalization field to the listing, or agree on details by message and create a custom listing.
  • Amazon: personalization runs through Amazon Custom. Per the Handmade page, “Custom products must be fulfilled by the seller and can’t be fulfilled through Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA).”

Shipping is where Amazon has a clear advantage for non-custom items. With FBA, you send stock to Amazon’s warehouses and Amazon handles storage, packing, delivery, customer service and returns, and your items become eligible for Prime. If FBA is new to you, our guide to Amazon FBA explains how it works and what it costs. Etsy has no fulfillment service: you ship every order yourself, though you can buy shipping labels through Etsy.

🎯 Pro Insight: FBA suits makers who produce in batches: soap, candles, ceramics in set designs. If every piece is made to order or personalized, you’ll ship yourself on either platform, so FBA’s advantage disappears.

Print on Demand, Digital Files and Supplies: Where Etsy Wins

If your business depends on any of these, the choice is made for you:

Product type Etsy Amazon Handmade
Your design printed by a production partner Allowed, partner must be disclosed Not allowed (outsourced production)
Digital downloads (patterns, printables) Allowed if made or designed by you Not allowed
Craft supplies Allowed Mostly not allowed (limited exceptions)
Vintage (20+ years old) Allowed Not allowed, unless you repurpose or upcycle it yourself

Amazon does sell some of these categories outside Handmade, just not under Handmade’s rules or fee. Print on demand, for example, runs through Amazon’s separate Merch on Demand program.

Which Should You Choose: Amazon Handmade or Etsy?

There’s no single winner. Use the profile that sounds most like your business:

If you… Start with Why
Are testing your first products Etsy No application, low cost per listing, buyers looking for handmade
Sell print on demand, digital files, supplies or vintage Etsy Amazon Handmade doesn’t allow them
Sell mostly personalized, made-to-order pieces Etsy, then add Amazon Custom Pre-sale messaging; FBA isn’t available for custom items anyway
Sell low-priced items (under about $8) Amazon Handmade Etsy’s fixed $0.45 per order weighs more on small orders
Make in batches and want someone else to ship Amazon Handmade with FBA Storage, shipping and returns handled; Prime eligibility
Have passed $10,000 a year on Etsy with many Offsite Ads orders Add Amazon Handmade Etsy’s 12% Offsite Ads fee is permanent at that point
Sell outside North America and Europe Etsy Amazon Handmade runs in 8 stores only

On the last row: Amazon’s Handmade regions page lists the US, Canada and Mexico, plus the UK, Germany, France, Italy and Spain. A maker in India, for example, can’t sell Handmade on amazon.in, while Etsy accepts sellers there (Etsy charges Indian shops 5% + 25 INR for processing).

Selling on Both: Moving Listings from Etsy to Amazon

Plenty of makers run both shops, and Amazon makes room for it: it publishes a help page on transferring product details from Etsy to Amazon Handmade. You can’t upload your Etsy CSV export directly, though. You copy its columns into an Amazon inventory template.

The step that trips people up is the title. Amazon caps titles for new listings at 75 characters, including spaces. Etsy titles are often long strings of search phrases, so most need rewriting before upload.

Amazon Seller Central product title requirements: titles must not exceed 75 characters including spaces, no promotional phrases, no special characters such as ! $ ?
Amazon’s product title requirements for new listings (Seller Central help, version 21, checked October 30, 2026).

Amazon’s title requirements also ban promotional phrases like “free shipping”, symbols such as ! $ ?, and using the same word more than twice. Amazon says non-compliant titles on existing listings “might be automatically corrected” or might not appear in search.

One more check if you make toys or baby products. Amazon.com sellers must get commercial liability insurance within 30 days of passing $10,000 in sales in a month. From November 2, 2026, sellers in categories with enhanced safety requirements, which include children’s toys and infant and toddler sleep products, need a $1 million policy “regardless of your gross sales proceeds,” per Amazon’s insurance requirements page. Budget for it before you list those items on Amazon.

📌 From Our Experience: Start with your 5 to 10 best Etsy sellers rather than the whole shop. Rewrite each title to Amazon’s format (what it is, material, size, color), keep the Etsy listing live, and compare both channels after a few months before moving more.

Buying Handmade Gifts: Etsy or Amazon Handmade?

If you’re shopping rather than selling, the same rules shape what you get. On Etsy, you can message the maker before ordering, which suits personalized gifts like bridesmaid presents with names or dates. Return terms vary by shop, so read each listing’s policy.

On Amazon, handmade items sit in their own Handmade store, and you can filter there instead of searching the whole site.

Amazon.com Handmade store page with its own category navigation, captured October 2026
The Handmade store on Amazon.com, captured October 2026.

Handmade makers must accept returns within 30 days, but personalized items are excluded unless something went wrong. For a personalized gift on a deadline, check the production time on either site before you order.

After You List on Amazon: Watching What Changes

One difference makers often miss: an Amazon detail page can change after you publish it, and Amazon may correct titles that break its rules. It’s worth checking your listings regularly once you sell there.

Here’s what a change looks like in SellerSonar, on a product that isn’t handmade. On October 30, 2026, the title of a Levoit air purifier (ASIN B09GTRVJQM) on Amazon.com grew from 73 to 187 characters. SellerSonar’s Title changed alert showed the old and new title and flagged “Filter” as a restricted keyword in the new one.

SellerSonar Title changed alert for Levoit air purifier B09GTRVJQM on October 30, 2026, showing the old and new title and a Restricted Keywords flag on the word Filter
A real Title changed alert from October 30, 2026, on an Amazon.com listing we track (not a handmade product).

SellerSonar monitors Amazon listings only, not Etsy. For a Handmade seller, it covers what Amazon controls:

  • Content changes: alerts when your title, bullet points, description, images or brand change.
  • New sellers on your listing: the “Seller appeared” alert. Buy Box and pricing alerts are off by default, so switch them on in Alerts, then Delivery Settings.
  • Search rank: daily organic and sponsored positions for the keywords you add.

Checks run every 4 hours on Pro, every 2 hours on Premium and every hour on Business and Enterprise, and alerts go out from the check that finds the change. All 8 Handmade stores are among the 23 Amazon marketplaces it covers. See how product monitoring works.

Final Verdict

Etsy is the easier start and the cheaper channel on a standard sale above about $8, and it’s the only option for print on demand, digital files, supplies and vintage. Its Offsite Ads fee is the cost to watch as you grow.

Amazon Handmade costs a flat 15% with no listing or monthly fee after month one, adds FBA and Prime for batch-made goods, and puts your products in front of shoppers in regular Amazon search. The price is stricter rules: an application, maker-only production, 30-day returns and short titles.

For most makers, the practical answer is both: build on Etsy, then add your best-selling, non-custom products to Amazon Handmade and compare the numbers. If you do list on Amazon, SellerSonar can keep an eye on those listings for you. You can try it free for 14 days, with 5 ASINs and 10 keywords and no credit card.

Frequently Asked Questions
How much does Etsy take from a $100 sale?

How much does Etsy take from a $100 sale?
Is Amazon Handmade cheaper than Etsy?

Is Amazon Handmade cheaper than Etsy?
What is the downside of selling on Etsy?

What is the downside of selling on Etsy?
Is Amazon Handmade worth it?

Is Amazon Handmade worth it?
Can I sell on both Amazon Handmade and Etsy?

Can I sell on both Amazon Handmade and Etsy?
Can I sell print on demand on Amazon Handmade?

Can I sell print on demand on Amazon Handmade?
Do I need approval to sell on Etsy or Amazon Handmade?

Do I need approval to sell on Etsy or Amazon Handmade?
Is it better to buy personalized gifts on Etsy or Amazon Handmade?

Is it better to buy personalized gifts on Etsy or Amazon Handmade?